In 2026, unsealed court documents laid bare the extent of the rift within the Murdoch family, exposing a succession battle over the future of one of the world’s most powerful media empires.
[See also: The Spear’s Tax and Trust Indices 2026]
Rupert Murdoch had sought to change the arrangements governing his family trust to ensure his son Lachlan would retain control, rather than leave voting power equally divided among his four eldest children. The move was challenged by his other three children, who opposed the proposed changes, and a Nevada court-appointed commissioner found that Rupert and Lachlan had acted in ‘bad faith’.
Explore the full 2026 Spear’s Tax & Trust Indices:
- Tax Lawyers
- Probate and Wills Lawyers
- Tax and Trust Barristers
- Accountants and Tax Advisers
- Trusts, Structuring and Offshore
For UHNW families, trust disputes like Murdoch’s are rarely just a legal matter; they are deeply personal and often tied to legacy, succession and pride.

‘If you have seen the TV series Succession, you’ll know there are corporate machinations,’ said George Porter of Winston Taylor, ranked as a Rising Star in this year’s index. ‘That is the best way to describe what we do as a team: Succession. It’s usually not about money but about wanting to be the top dog.’
[See also: Do HMRC’s letters to billionaires spell the end of ‘complete privacy’?]
Themes in 2026
The Spear’s Contentious Trust Lawyers Index highlights the industry’s top advisers who use legal nous, expert precision and emotional intelligence to navigate disputes arising between trustees and beneficiaries.
The lawyers featured lead some of the UK’s highest-profile matters; John Tunnard of Shakespeare Martineau, for example, was involved in the Earl of Yarmouth case relating to the Ragley Estate, valued at £85 million.
Avoiding court
While it is often the case that contentious trust lawyers find themselves at home in the courtroom, a growing number of advisers in the Spear’s index are resolving issues discreetly.

Christian Hay of Collas Crill, a new addition to this year’s index, is a strong advocate of alternative dispute resolution and is one of the few accredited mediators and arbitration specialists in the Guernsey trusts sector.
Advisers can handle breach of trust accusations, disputes over fiduciary duty and capacity challenges to wills through mediation or arbitration, without going to court.
[See also: How non-court dispute resolution is changing family law]
Caroline Tayler of Winston Taylor noted the growing interest in trust arbitration among her UHNW clients. ‘It is a more private and efficient alternative to court proceedings.’
Advisers under scrutiny
Another growing trend in 2026 is UK courts’ increased willingness to penalise professional advisers who they consider to be negligent due to the poor drafting of a trust or will document.
‘It’s a recognition that instead of a client having to privately fund proceedings, the cost will fall on the adviser because this litigation was caused by them drafting incorrectly,’ noted Tunnard.
However, he warns, issues related to poor advice may take years to come to light: ‘A will can be drafted a long time ago and only at the point of death will the beneficiary notice something is not right.’
[See also: The costly consequences of poorly drafted family trusts]
From handling complex cases involving capacity issues to ushering the buyout of a long-time trustee, the lawyers featured in this year’s contentious trust law index can guide clients through disputes both in and out of court. Combining a meticulous technical knowledge of trust and probate structures with the emotional intelligence required to deal with struggling families, they excel at getting the right result for their clients’ needs.
Click the links below to jump to a section of this article
- Methodology
- The best contentious trust lawyers: some names to know
- The best contentious trust lawyers: the complete list
- Contact us
Methodology
Each year, the Spear’s Research Unit reassesses and refreshes its rankings of the leading providers in each sector by gathering data from and about the advisers and firms themselves, assessing submission forms, collating nominations, carrying out peer reviews, reviewing data from third-party sources, gathering references and recommendations, canvassing experts and conducting hundreds of interviews.
Advisers are evaluated using a proprietary scoring system that assigns different weightings to certain attributes. These scores feed directly into each new set of rankings in the Spear’s Indices. Each of these indices are published first online (according to the research calendar) and then in print. Print publication takes the form of the annual Spear’s 500 directory, which includes the top advisers in every index.
[See also: A guide to The Spear’s 500: Everything you need to know]
Each featured adviser is profiled on spears500.com. The site allows users to search the Spear’s database of more than 4,000 entities to find one (or more) to meet their specific requirements by filtering for specific attributes such as an adviser’s location, their specialist expertise and information about their client base.
The best contentious trust lawyers: some names to know
Claire-Marie Cornford
- Focus: Trust, estate and succession disputes
- Ranking: Top Recommended
- Firm: Irwin Mitchell
Claire-Marie Cornford joined Irwin Mitchell in 2017, having been headhunted from her previous role at Mishcon de Reya, to join the firm’s newly formed private wealth division. As head of wills, trust and estate disputes in London, she leads a dedicated team of lawyers, including a second partner who specialises in Court of Protection cases.

Overseeing a group of specialised lawyers who represent a broad range of clients, including successful entrepreneurs and business leaders, landed gentry, farmers, charities, trustees and HNWs, Cornford deals with the full range of contentious trusts and estates matters, whether that is probate or trust disputes, claims under the Inheritance Act 1975 or international succession disputes.
Read Claire-Marie Cornford’s full profile on Spears500.com
Charlotte Fraser
- Focus: Fraud and asset tracing
- Ranking: Recommended
- Firm: Farrer & Co
Charlotte Fraser joined Farrer & Co in 2006 as a trainee solicitor after graduating from the University of Oxford. Having climbed up the ladder, she became a partner at the firm in 2017 and now leads its contentious trusts and estates team.

Taking on both onshore and offshore disputes, Fraser is adept at navigating multifacted, multi-jurisdictional cases, as well as complex family situations. She frequently advises on matters involving accusations of fraud or breach of trust, contested wills and claims under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. Her diverse clientele pool includes beneficiaries, trustees, executors and settlors.
Read Charlotte Fraser’s full profile on Spears500.com
Caroline Tayler
- Focus: Trust and succession disputes
- Ranking: Recommended
- Firm: Winston Taylor
Caroline Tayler is a partner and head of Winston Taylor’s contentious trust and estates practice. She describes her team as ‘pure litigators’, who are as equally comfortable with ‘aggressive, hard-fought litigation’ as they are with mediation or arbitration.

In addition to highly complex disputes involving substantial and diverse family wealth, Tayler is equipped to navigate trust disputes arising out of divorce, for example where one partner attempts to hide a trust from the other, and professional negligence matters. Cases often have an international aspect, and Taylor has a large client base in Asia. Many cases, she tells Spear’s, involve younger members of multigenerational Asian families who want to structure their wealth differently to older generations.
Read Caroline Tayler’s full profile on Spears500.com
Jessica Henson
- Focus: Trust and estate disputes
- Ranking: Top Recommended
- Firm: Payne Hicks Beach
Jessica Henson is a partner in Payne Hicks Beach’s well-regarded private client team, specialising in disputed trusts and estates.

Her practice includes probate disputes – especially cases in which divorce has complicated matters – capacity and construction issues, and claims under the Inheritance Act 1975.
‘Because of all the experience I have with disputes, I find myself doing quite a lot of advisory work trying to prevent disputes from arising,’ she tells Spear’s. This involves advising on structures such as wills and prenuptial agreements that lay out what should be done in the event of future divorces, power holders losing capacity or any deaths that may occur.
Read Jessica Henson’s full profile on Spears500.com
Kirstie McGuigan
- Focus: Conflict prevention and resolution
- Ranking: Recommended
- Firm: Winston Taylor
Kirstie McGuigan, a private client partner at Winston Taylor, specialises in contentious and non-contentious trust and estate matters. Her clients are primarily multi-generational, (U)HNW families.

On the contentious side, she acts on disputes relating to the formation or administration of trusts and estates – which are often large and complex – in the UK and internationally. These disputes often involve claims under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, or capacity issues.
As part of her non-contentious work, McGuigan advises individuals and families on estate, succession and tax planning; clients also include trustees of high-value trusts.
Read Kirstie McGuigan’s full profile on Spears500.com
Lynsey Harrison
- Focus: Contentious probate
- Ranking: Recommended
- Firm: Clarion Solicitors
Lynsey Harrison, head of the contentious private client and court of protection teams at Clarion Solicitors, is ‘not interested in point scoring’. For her, what matters most is that clients ‘feel safe, trust me and feel like I have their back’.

With more than two decades of experience, Harrison advises on a broad range of private wealth disputes, from contested trusts and wills to lack of capacity and undue influence challenges, Inheritance Act claims, statutory wills and contentious statutory wills.
She particularly enjoys the forensic side of litigation: tracing money, unpicking asset structuring and following the evidence trail to establish what has happened.
Read Lynsey Harrison’s full profile on Spears500.com
Scott Taylor Edwards
- Focus: Estate disputes
- Ranking: Recommended
- Firm: Moore Barlow
Scott Taylor Edwards heads up Moore Barlow’s private wealth disputes team, which he says is recognised for advising on ‘complex, high-value and high-profile matters’, often with an international aspect.

A well-regarded litigator, Taylor specialises in cases involving allegations of lack of testamentary capacity, undue influence, want of knowledge and approval, as well as claims under the Inheritance Act 1975.
Taylor, who is experienced in handling cases both in the High Court and Court of Protection, says this often involves alternative dispute resolution methods, such as mediation.
Read Scott Taylor Edwards’s full profile on Spears500.com
The best contentious trust lawyers: the complete list
Click on the individual names to be directed to more detailed profiles of each adviser on The Spear’s 500 website. The table is ordered by ranking and then alphabetically by surname.
Contact us
- Click here to order a print copy of The Spear’s 500.
- To apply for inclusion in The Spear’s 500, complete our submission form.
- For further information about rankings, please email research@spearswms.com; we aim to respond to all queries within two working days.
- For commercial enquiries and questions relating to enhanced profiles, please contact: sales@spearswms.com
- To keep up to date with the Spear’s 500, subscribe to our magazine, newsletter and follow Spear’s on Linkedin and Instagram.
- If you have missed calendar deadlines for our research cycles in 2026, you can still register your interest for updates about upcoming research and rankings.
With additional reporting by Caitlin Kilpatrick.





